lol下注

中国学者《科学》论文首被撤稿 举报者:可以重做研究再提交
资讯

中国学者《科学》论文首被撤稿 举报者:可以重做研究再提交

2020年10月10日 16:12:44
来源:澎湃新闻

lol下注10yue9ri,yinliangchu“tupianyiwaicuowu”,youzhongguoxuezhezhuanxiedeyipiantiwei“proton transport enabled by a field-induced metallic state in a semiconductor heterostructure”(《dianchangyoudaoyizhijiemianjinshutaigoujianchaozhizichuanshu》)delunwenbeiscience《kexue》qikanchegao。

lol下注ju《zhongguokexuebao》baodao,zheishizhongguoxuezhesciencelunwenshoucibeiche。

lol下注zheipianchegaowenzhangdediyizuozheshizhongguodizhidaxue(wuhan)cailiaoyuhuaxuexueyuanfujiaoshouwuyan,gongtongtongxunzuozhefenbieshidongnandaxuenengyuanyuhuanjingxueyuanlianhechunengyanjiuzhongxinshouxikexuejiazhubinhezhongguodizhidaxue(wuhan)cailiaoyuhuaxuexueyuanfujiaoshousonghuaibing。

lunwengong12weishumingzuozhe,chuzhubindeng4weizuozhebujieshouchegaojuedingzhiwai,tuanduizhongqita8renbaokuowuyan、songhuaibingjunzhichichegao,bingyusciencewangzhanfabu“chegaoshengming”,chengduiyanjiuzhongde“yiwaicuowu”(accidental mistakes) fuquanbuzeren。

撤稿声明原文 图片来源于Science

chegaoshengmingyuanwen tupianlaiyuanyusciencetongyichegaode8weizuozhezai“chegaoshengming”zhongzhichu,yanjiubaogaozhongdeliangchu“tupiancuowu”hedangshidediyuweizhiyurenyuanbiandongxiangguan。tuanduicheng,zaigaiyanjiushouweijieduan(2019nian12yuezhongxunzhi2020nian3yue),yushangwuhanyinweixinguanfeiyanyiqing“fengcheng”,zuozhemendangshiyefengezaibutongdechengshi、guojia,wufashiyongwuhandeshiyanshijisuanjihuoshujukuziyuan,yizhiyuzuozhezhijian“goutongyouwu”,chuxiantupianshiyongbudang。

shangshu8weizuozhecheng,jinguanyanjiuzhongcunzai“yiwaicuowu”,danshitamenrengranduiyanjiudeshiyansheji、lilunyansuan、zhuyaodeshujufenxideng“biaoshizhichi”。

10yue9ri,pengpaixinwentongguoyoujianlianxidongnandaxuenengyuanyuhuanjingxueyuanlianhechunengyanjiuzhongxinshouxikexuejiazhubinyijiduocizhidianzhongguodizhidaxue(wuhan)dangweixuanchuanbu,jiezhifagaoshangweishoudaoduifanghuiying。

juguojizhuanmentaolunxueshuyanjiufabiaojiyanjiuchengxinyitidewangzhan“chegaoguancha”(retraction watch)xiaoxicheng,butongyichegaodezhubintongguoyoujianhuiyingbiaoshi,suirancunzaicuowu,danyanjiubenshenjuyoudulixing、zhenshixinghekezhongfuxing,《kexue》keyiduiyouwentidewenzhangjinxingkanwu,bubizhijiechegao。

gongkaiziliaoxianshi,retraction watchchengliyu2010nian8yue,chuangbanrenshikexuejizhe、bianjichushendeivan oranskyyuadam marcus。

10yue10ri,cengjubaogailunwentupianshiyongbudangdeguojixueshudajiazhuanjiaelisabeth bikjieshoupengpaixinwencaifangshibiaoshi,ruguoyixiangyanjiuyinweishoudaozhiyibeiqikanbianjibujiyuguanzhu,jishizheixiangyanjiushikezhongfude,yebunengshiqizidongmianchuguanzhu。(chegaohou)zuozheyibanshikeyizhongzuogaiyanjiubingjiangqizhongxintijiaojitongyiqikan,dantamentijiaodegongzuohuizaicijingguozhengchangdetongxingpingshenliucheng。

lol下注shangshusheshilunwenfabiaoyu7yue10ri。zhongguodizhidaxueguanwangdebaodaocheng,gaiyanjiuweiyouliangzhizichuanshucailiaoheyingyongtigonglechuangxinsilu,weizhizixianyuchuanshutigonglekexuefangfa。

buguo,suihouzhongguokepuzuojia、wangluomingrenfangzhouziduigaiwenzhangtichulezhiyi。zheiyinqileguojixueshudajiazhuanjiaelisabeth bikdezhuyi,lianggeyueqiantazaitongxingpingshenpingtaipubpeertichuyiwen,zhiyijiaodianjizhongzailunwendeliangzhangtupianshang:

diyi,gaiyanjiuzhongdetus10(xiatuzuo)he2017nianfabiaodeyipianlunwen“enhanced ionic conductivity of yttria-stabilized zro2 with natural cufe-oxide mineral heterogeneous composite for low temperature solid oxide fuel cells”( doi:10.1016 / j.ijhydene.2017.05.218)detu8a(xiatuyou)gaoduxiangsi。

两篇论文中高度相似的两张图,红色框显示两个图形之间看起来相似的区域。黄色标记是原始图形的一部分。 图片来源于PubPeer

liangpianlunwenzhonggaoduxiangsideliangzhangtu,hongsekuangxianshilianggetuxingzhijiankanqilaixiangsidequyu。huangsebiaojishiyuanshituxingdeyibufen。 tupianlaiyuanyupubpeerdier,gaiyanjiudetus9b(xiatuzuo)youhe2018nianfabiaodelunwen“the composite electrolyte with an insulation sm2o3 and semiconductor nio for advanced fuel cells”( doi:10.1016 / j.ijhydene.2018.03.184)zhongdetu8(xiatuyou)gaoduxiangsi。

两篇论文的图片高度相似  图片来源于PubPeer

liangpianlunwendetupiangaoduxiangsi tupianlaiyuanyupubpeererqie,shangshusanpianwenzhangdetongxunzuozhedouyouzhubin。

judongnandaxuenengyuanyuhuanjingxueyuanguanwangjieshao,zhubinjiaoshouzuoweiranliaodianchiyanjiufangxiangdejianduanrencai,qizaixinxingranliaodianchiyingyongheduolianchanxitong、bandaotijiranliaodianchihegutidianchiyijinengyuanzhuanhuahechucunyitihuayanjiufangxiangqudelefengshuochengguo。zaicailiaohenengyuandengguojidingjiqikanfabiaolunwen300duopian,yinyong7500duoci,h-yinzi46,chuanglilebandaotilizixue,yinlingguojiranliaodianchifazhandexinfangxiang。tongshi,zhubinshiruidianhuangjiagongxueyuanjiaoshou、nanjingnamikejihexianjinranliaodianchigongsidongshihuizhuxi。

《kexue》qikandezhubianh. holden thorpyu9yue4riduishangshuzhiyizuochulehuiying,bingduigaiyanjiubiaoshi“bianjibuguanzhu”(editorial expression of concern),mingquetichuyaoqiuzuozhetuanduiduicijinxingchengqing。

lol下注10yue9ri,gaituanduichengrenyanjiuzhongdeliangchutupianshiyongcuowu,bingjichu“shiwuyuanyin”: 1)benyanjiudetus10xianqianyibeicunchuyushiyanshujukuzhong,danmeiduigaitujinxingbiaozhushuoming,jisuanjishujucongyigexueshengzhuanyidaolingyigexueshengshifashenglecicuowu。2)yinshujubeicuowudibaocunzaitongyiwenjianjiazhong,benyanjiudetus9bcuowudibaohanle2018nianfabudeyanjiu(doi: 10.1016 / j.ijhydene.2018.03.184)tu8deshuju。

lol下注ciqian,elisabeth bikhuiying“chegaoguancha”biaoshi,zuozhedeliyousuiranheli,danbujinrangwaijieduishujudeyouxiaoxing,shenzhiduizhenggeyanjiudeyouxiaoxingdouchanshenglezhiyi。chegaoshigebucuodejueding,xiwangzheicicuowunenggoutixingyanjiuzhegenghaodijilushiyanshujuhewenjianming。

lol下注pengpaixinwenzhuyidao,10yue10ri,zhongguodizhidaxueguanwangguanyu《dianchangyoudaoyizhijiemianjinshutaigoujianchaozhizichuanshu》debaodaoyibeichexia。

天津园林绿化公司|绿化养护|别墅庭院景观|天津绿化施工|私家园林-天津诺诚建设工程有限公司